Should’ve been open, should’ve done more Should’ve learned a lesson from the year before Should've been honest, should’ve just cried Should’ve told me there was nothing left inside
Now the road keeps rollin’ on forever And the years keep pulling us apart We lost something, I still wonder what it was It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it does
You should've just broken, you should've come clean You should've been sad instead bein' so fuckin' mean It shouldn't be easy, but it shouldn't be hard You shouldn't be a stranger in your own backyard Now the road keeps rollin’ on forever And the years keep pulling us apart I know it's over, I'm just sayin' this because It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it does
I shouldn't be angry, I shouldn't hold on I shouldn't leave messages in every little song It could've been always, it could've been me We could've been busy naming baby number three
Now the road keeps rollin’ on forever And the years keep pulling us apart If it's on someone, I blame the both of us It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it It shouldn't matter, shouldn't matter but it does